I am a girl to start off with haha Anyway, today I was shopping at American Eagle. I bought two pairs of shorts that fit great, both size 2. But I bought a third pair and tried them on. They are a size 4. But, are too tight. Why is it that? The other two pairs of shorts (size 2) fit fine! Will these size 4 stretch or should I go up a size? I'm just confused because in everything else at AE I am a size 2 and it fits fine.I am a girl to start off with haha Anyway, today I was shopping at American Eagle. I bought two pairs of shorts that fit great, both size 2. But I bought a third pair and tried them on. They are a size 4. But, are too tight. Why is it that? The other two pairs of shorts (size 2) fit fine! Will these size 4 stretch or should I go up a size? I'm just confused because in everything else at AE I am a size 2 and it fits fine.

All shorts are made different. If they're too tight, then go up a size. Numbers don't matter as much as comfort.

Not sure why they fit different but I would probably bet they will loosen up a bit.